DENIED IDENTITY: EXAMINING THE INFRINGEMENT OF FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS THROUGH THE BAN ON CASTE DECAL FOR VEHICLES

Caste and religious decals on cars have drawn a lot of attention, particularly considering the Uttar Pradesh police’s recent enforcement campaign against them. Numerous court rulings and orders have emphasised the ban on these decals, highlighting issues with social harmony and public order. Nonetheless, objections to these prohibitions have been made, pointing out that the Indian Constitution’s fundamental rights have been violated.

Three fundamental rights—Article 14 (Equality before the law), Article 19 (Freedom of speech and expression), and Article 21 (Protection of life and personal liberty)—intersect with the ban on caste and religious decals. Since Article 14 guarantees equality and the protection of the law, banning these decals might be unfair and discriminatory. It is implied that prohibiting these decals may limit expression, association, and identity assertion whereas, Article 19 protects the freedoms of speech, association, and movement. The protection of the right to life and liberty, which includes autonomy and dignity, is provided by Article 21. This right may be jeopardised by restricting speech and upholding discrimination.

These prohibitions are still in effect despite legal challenges, and violations are subject to fines under certain provisions of the Motor Vehicle Act. But since the Act doesn’t specifically forbid caste or religious decals, it’s unclear whether the fines levied for their display are justified. Furthermore, the Act usually permits small modifications, such as stickers, provided they don’t change the fundamental design of the vehicles.

The prohibitions on religious and caste decals seek to address social issues, but to be justified as constitutional, they must pass the reasonableness test. Navigating this complicated issue requires striking a balance between societal interests and individual freedoms to protect both that is our fundamental rights and advance inclusivity and social harmony.