LIJDLR

Personal Laws

MINORITY RIGHTS AND THE POSITION OF WOMEN IN INDIA: A CONSTITUTIONAL ANALYSIS

Volume IV Issue I /

MINORITY RIGHTS AND THE POSITION OF WOMEN IN INDIA: A CONSTITUTIONAL ANALYSIS Shunmuga Sundarakumar G, Assistant Professor, Government Law College, Tirunelveli (India) Download Manuscript doi.org/10.70183/lijdlr.2026.v04.133 The protection of minority rights constitutes a fundamental pillar of India’s constitutional framework, reflecting its commitment to pluralism, secularism, and social justice in a diverse society. The Constitution guarantees a range of rights aimed at safeguarding minority communities, including equality before the law, non-discrimination, freedom of religion, and cultural and educational autonomy. However, within these communities, women occupy a particularly vulnerable position due to the intersection of gender and minority status, which exposes them to multiple and overlapping forms of discrimination. This paper adopts doctrinal method and undertakes a constitutional analysis of minority rights in India, with a specific focus on examining the position and protection of women within minority communities. The study critically analyses key constitutional provisions such as Articles 14, 15, 21, and 25 to 30, alongside the evolving jurisprudence developed by the Supreme Court of India in landmark decisions. The analysis reveals that despite the existence of a robust constitutional and legal framework, minority women continue to face persistent challenges, including discriminatory personal laws, socio-economic marginalization, limited access to education and healthcare, lack of political representation, and heightened vulnerability to violence and discrimination, especially during communal tensions. The paper argues that a significant gap exists between formal legal guarantees and their effective implementation on the ground. It concludes that achieving substantive equality for minority women requires a gender-sensitive, rights-based approach that harmonizes minority rights with constitutional values. Strengthening legal awareness, reforming discriminatory practices, and ensuring effective policy implementation are essential to advancing the protection and empowerment of minority women in India.

MINORITY RIGHTS AND THE POSITION OF WOMEN IN INDIA: A CONSTITUTIONAL ANALYSIS Read More »

PERSONAL LAWS VS. CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS: THE ROLE OF JUDICIAL PROCESS IN ADVANCING GENDER JUSTICE

Volume III Issue IV /

PERSONAL LAWS VS. CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS: THE ROLE OF JUDICIAL PROCESS IN ADVANCING GENDER JUSTICE Dhriti Kochhar, LL.M. (Criminology), IILM University, Noida (India) Download Manuscript doi.org/10.70183/lijdlr.2025.v03.182 Indian courts face a difficult challenge: how to balance religious personal laws with the Constitution’s promise of equality and justice for all citizens. This conflict is most visible in women’s rights cases, where religious traditions often deny women equal treatment. Important cases like Mohd. Ahmed Khan v. Shah Bano Begum (1985), Danial Latifi v. Union of India (2001), Shayara Bano v. Union of India (2017), and ongoing cases like Sameena Begum v. Union of India on polygamy and nikah halala show how courts are trying to protect women’s rights while respecting religious freedom. This research uses three methods. First, it studies laws and court judgments to see how judges have dealt with this problem. Second, it compares India with other countries like Islamic nations and the United Kingdom to learn how they handle similar issues. Third, it analyzes whether court decisions actually help women or go beyond what courts should do. The research also looks at the Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala (1973) case, which says courts must protect the Constitution’s basic principles. The paper argues that while court decisions have pushed for social change and helped women, real progress needs three things working together: courts protecting rights, Parliament making new laws, and society accepting these changes.

PERSONAL LAWS VS. CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS: THE ROLE OF JUDICIAL PROCESS IN ADVANCING GENDER JUSTICE Read More »

DOMESTIC VIOLENCE, MAINTENANCE, AND WOMEN’S RIGHTS: A CROSS-PERSONAL LAW PERSPECTIVE IN INDIA

Volume III Issue IV /

DOMESTIC VIOLENCE, MAINTENANCE, AND WOMEN’S RIGHTS: A CROSS-PERSONAL LAW PERSPECTIVE IN INDIA Ms. Palak Jha, 3rd Semester, Student at IILM University, Greater Noida (India) Download Manuscript doi.org/10.70183/lijdlr.2025.v03.131 Domestic violence and women’s right to maintenance constitute two deeply interlinked dimensions of gender justice in India. Despite substantial legal reforms and constitutional guarantees, Indian women continue to face systemic inequalities rooted in the coexistence of personal laws that differ across religious lines. The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 represents a secular legislative attempt to address intimate partner violence and ensure protection, residence, and maintenance rights. However, this uniform civil protection contrasts sharply with the diverse personal laws that regulate marriage, divorce, and post-marital support within distinct religious communities, Hindus, Muslims, Christians, and Parsis. This research paper examines the structural, constitutional, and judicial complexities that arise from this pluralistic legal framework. It examines how personal laws intersect with constitutional principles of equality, dignity, and non-discrimination, and the extent to which Indian courts have harmonized religious autonomy with gender justice. Through doctrinal and analytical methodologies, the study reviews statutory provisions, landmark judgments, and scholarly literature to evaluate whether the Indian legal system has achieved substantive justice for women or continues to entrench religious and gender hierarchies. The paper argues that while progressive judicial interpretations, particularly in Mohd. Ahmed Khan v Shah Bano Begum, Danial Latifi v Union of India, and Indra Sarma v V K V Sarma have advanced the cause of women’s rights within a constitutional framework; however, the absence of uniformity across personal laws continues to limit the effectiveness of these protections. The study concludes that only through harmonization of personal laws within the constitutional fabric can India fulfil its commitment to gender equality and human dignity.

DOMESTIC VIOLENCE, MAINTENANCE, AND WOMEN’S RIGHTS: A CROSS-PERSONAL LAW PERSPECTIVE IN INDIA Read More »

PROBING THE PRACTICALITY OF UNIFORM CIVIL CODE IN INDIA

Volume II Issue II /

PROBING THE PRACTICALITY OF UNIFORM CIVIL CODE IN INDIA Masooma Naqvi, Student at Amity University, Uttar Pradesh Download Manuscript ABSTRACT Uniform Civil Code provides for bringing the entire country under one civil law. Although it was encoded in the Indian Constitution with the intention of fostering national integrity and unity, it remains a disputed upon topic in India. This paper delves into probing the actual practicality of enforcing the Uniform Civil Code in India. It examines the Uniform Civil Code Bill of 2019 and delves into the analysis of its provisions, aims and objectives.  Its objective is to understand whether it was actually needed and if it interferes with any of the Fundamental rights that are guaranteed to the citizens of India under part III of the Indian Constitution. The paper also seeks to comprehensively analyze the problems with the Uniform Civil Code and whether sticking to the status quo is a viable solution. The paper also seeks to delve into the complexities involved, and the political, legal and social aspects behind the implementation of Uniform Civil Code. Type Information Research Paper LawFoyer International Journal of Doctrinal Legal Research, Volume II, Issue II, Page 375-385. Creative Commons Copyright This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License. Copyright © LIJDLR 2024

PROBING THE PRACTICALITY OF UNIFORM CIVIL CODE IN INDIA Read More »

HARMONIZING DIVERSITY: THE QUEST FOR A UNIFORM CIVIL CODE

Volume I Issue II /

HARMONIZING DIVERSITY: THE QUEST FOR A UNIFORM CIVIL CODE Indisha Sachan, Law student at Amity Law School, Lucknow. Download Manuscript ABSTRACT In a world characterized by diverse cultures, religions, and traditions, the challenge of harmonizing diversity becomes paramount for fostering social cohesion and ensuring equal rights and justice for all. India is a country of immense diversity, with different religions, cultures, languages, and traditions coexisting in a pluralistic society. However, this diversity also poses challenges for the legal system, which has to deal with the personal laws of various communities that govern matters such as marriage, divorce, inheritance, adoption, and maintenance. The Uniform Civil Code (UCC) is a proposal to replace these personal laws with a standard set of laws that would apply to all citizens irrespective of their religion, gender, or sexual orientation. The UCC has been a contentious issue in Indian politics and society for decades, with supporters arguing that it would promote national integration, gender justice, and human rights, while opponents claim that it would violate the constitutional guarantee of religious freedom and the cultural identity of minorities. This paper examines the historical background, constitutional provisions, judicial pronouncements, and socio-political implications of the UCC debate in India. It analyzes the arguments for and against the UCC from various perspectives, such as secularism, democracy, feminism, minority rights, and legal reform. It also explores the feasibility and desirability of implementing the UCC in a country as diverse as India and suggests some possible ways to harmonize diversity with uniformity in the civil law domain. Type Information Research Paper LawFoyer International Journal of Doctrinal Legal Research, Volume I, Issue II, Page 416- 433. Creative Commons Copyright This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License. Copyright © LIJDLR 2023 Recent content HARMONIZING DIVERSITY: THE QUEST FOR A UNIFORM CIVIL CODE LEGALITY OF EUTHANASIA IN INDIA: RIGHT TO DIE WITH DIGNITY ANALYSIS ON MECHANISM OF CORPORATE GOVERNANCES IN INDIA VICTIMS PLIGHT: NEED FOR GROWTH OF VICTIMOLOGY IN INDIA A STROLL THROUGH THE STATE OF DIGITAL PRIVACY IN INDIA DOMESTIC VIOLENCE: THE GAP BETWEEN STATISTICS AND REALITY

HARMONIZING DIVERSITY: THE QUEST FOR A UNIFORM CIVIL CODE Read More »